1 Shares

If you’re a high school English teacher, you know grading can take over your life very easily. However, you can reduce the load by adopting a few new tricks & practices.

The following grading strategies are designed specifically for secondary ELA teachers who want to:

Cut grading time dramatically
Give better, more targeted feedback
Reduce their own feelings of burnout (especially during the busiest grading months)

Whether you teach Literature, Composition, or English Language Arts, these tips will help you have more free time and less stress!

What to Do Before Grading to Reduce Grading Time

1. Conference While Students Are Writing

Don’t wait until you are grading to give feedback. Instead, skim student work during class and have quick conversations with them about what you see.

These mini-conferences often replace the need for heavy written feedback later.

Pro tip:
Meet with faster workers early and slower workers later, and plan to do this over multiple workdays.

2. Use Color-Coding for Essays

Have students highlight key parts of their writing before submission:

Thesis → underline or bold
Claims → yellow
Evidence → green
Analysis → purple

This makes grading faster because you can instantly see their structure, organization, and intent. You’ll understand what they were trying to do more quickly.

3. Make Students Fill Out the Rubric First

Before submitting, students should assess their own work using the rubric.

This allows you to:

Focus feedback where it matters most to the student him or herself
Increase student ownership of the work and the grade
Avoid wasting time on feedback they won’t read; focus on what they thought they did poorly

Find my rubrics here!

4. Set “Minimum Requirements” for Grading

Create a checklist of basic expectations (capitalization, punctuation, MLA format, etc.).

If those aren’t met:

Return the assignment ungraded
Require resubmission within 24 hours

This one move alone can save hours of frustration! Don’t even START to read a paper that doesn’t meet your “bare minimums” list!

Free checklist 1

Free checklist 2

5. Grade Prewriting for Completion

Assign graphic organizers or outlines and quickly skim them looking for major issues. Address those issues with the students either via notes on their work or quick verbal conferencing during writing time the next day (or few days).

This leads to:

Stronger final drafts
Faster grading later
Better understanding of student intent

6. Use Timed In-Class Drafts (on Paper)

This reduces AI misuse and plagiarism issues.

Less academic dishonesty = less time spent investigating and documenting it.

Rubric Strategies That Cut Grading Time

1. Use a Single-Point Rubric

Only define the “proficient” level.

Then:

Add praise on one side
Add improvement notes on the other

This simplifies grading while keeping your feedback meaningful and understandable for the kids. It also encourages YOU to add more praise (if that’s something you often skimp on).

Find mine here!

2. Grade Only One (or a Few) Skills at a Time

Instead of grading everything, focus on:

One major skill
Or 2–3 targeted traits on your rubric

Students will still need to try their best if you don’t tell them which big skill or trait will be graded. Or, you can weight the 1-3 rubric areas you focused on during the unit or assignment at 80% and the rest of the rubric areas at 20%.

3. Use a Simple 3-Column Rubric

Try:

Needs Improvement
Meets Expectations
Exceeds Expectations

Just check a box and add short comments. No essay markup required! Most students will be okay with this, and those who want more feedback can come in for a verbal conference during your office hours!

Try this rubric

or these!

4. Weight the “Focus Skill” Heavily

If your unit focuses on organization, make it worth most of the grade (maybe 70%?).

This:

Reinforces your teaching
Encourages better questions from students during the unit (Tell them which skill is being weighted heavily as they are working on the essay)
Simplifies your own grading decisions

5. Give Completion Grades for Early Drafts

Skim your students’ first drafts. Save your more detailed feedback for their final drafts.

This works especially well with:

Chronic non-submitters
Students who struggle to get started

Make the first draft (rough draft) worth a significant number of points, and take away a LOT of points for late submission. This will encourage students to be more prompt with their final drafts and decrease the number of kids who’ve done nothing on the final day of in-class writing.

Teach revision with these lesson slides!

6. Borrow from AP Rubrics

Use ideas like the “sophistication point” to define what “exceeds expectations” looks like, even in non-AP classes!

Here’s mine…

Feedback Strategies That Actually Save Time

1. Try Grading Without Written Comments

Give only rubric scores and offer optional conferences for those who want more guidance or explanation from you.

Most students won’t request the conference, and you just saved hours.

2. Highlight One Strong Line

Pick a favorite sentence and highlight it or underline it, and then put a fun sticker next to it (or an emoji comment if you’re grading digitally).

It’s quick, positive, and meaningful for the students. This is a great way to increase your POSITIVE commenting if that’s an area of growth for you as a teacher.

3. Use the “One Glow, One Grow” Strategy

Limit your feedback to:

One strength
One area for improvement

Students are far more likely to actually use your feedback when there’s not so much of it as to overwhelm them!

4. Record Audio Feedback

Use tools like your LMS (Canvas, Turnitin, etc.) to leave voice comments.

Students are much more likely to listen than read. They also find this method more personal and engaging.

5. Do Whole-Class Editing (Anonymously)

Edit one student sample in front of the class.

Yes, this takes time, but it can replace repeated individual feedback. Choose an essay that represents the 2-3 main errors you saw and then grade it up on the board as the students watch. Have them comment, too. You just saved time not writing those comments over and over again on student essays! And they’ll LEARN more for next time this way as it’s a focused lesson.

6. Build a Comment Bank

Save frequently used comments so you can reuse them.

Over time, this will become one of your most powerful grading tools!

7. Use Text Expansion Tools

Programs like Text Blaze let you insert full comments with shortcuts.

Huge time-saver.

8. Use Emojis for Quick Feedback

Simple symbols (👍 👀 ✨) can communicate quickly and reduce overwriting.

9. Use Voice Typing

If speaking is faster than typing for you, use voice-to-text for end comments.

10. Limit Grammar Corrections

Only mark…

The first page
or the first 5 errors

Then require students to find and fix the rest and resubmit.

11. Create a Feedback Code System

Use shorthand like:

C = comma error
A = weak analysis
1 = poor hook
etc.

Print a master copy and have the kids keep it. Students can learn the system quickly, and you can write less.

Workflow Tips to Grade Faster

1. Sort Essays Before Grading (the Triage Method)

Group into:

Green (strong)
Yellow (average)
Red (needs major work)

Then grade strategically. I give more time to the yellow group than the other two. I also grade the groups separately. Then I have an idea what kind of grading I’m getting myself into when I sit down.

2. Grade in Small Daily Batches

Instead of marathon sessions, aim to complete…

5–10 essays per day

This is far more sustainable and can be done over lunch or during downtime in class.

3. Use the Pomodoro Method

Try:

20 minutes of grading
then a 10-minute break

This helps you stay focused longer.

4. Set a Time Limit Per Essay

Cap yourself at 5–6 minutes per essay.

Very few papers deserve 15 minutes! If the student messed up that badly, a verbal conference and revision would work better for both you and the student.

5. Address Patterns Once (Not 100 Times)

If you see repeated issues:

Write one general comment in a running document or on a legal pad.
Share these with the whole class on hand-back day.

6. Use Whole-Class Feedback Slides

Create a quick slideshow of…

Common mistakes
Strong examples (take screenshots or photos)

Now you can make feedback a lesson for the day and explain something once instead of repeating it.

Assignment Design That Reduces Grading Load

1. Assign Shorter Writing More Often

Use:

Paragraphs
1–2 page responses

Save full essays for the end of the year or semester.

2. Focus Each Assignment or Essay on One Main Skill

Teach it → practice it → assess it.

Simple and effective.

3. Use Partial Essays

Assign:

Thesis only
One body paragraph
Outlines

Not every assignment needs to be a full essay.

4. Use Peer Review (But Don’t Grade It Deeply)

Give participation credit and skim the peer comments for effort.

Don’t over-grade the process.

Teach revision with these lesson slides!

What to Do After Grading to Reduce Your Future Workload

1. Require a 3-Sentence Reflection

Students should identify:

One strength
One improvement area
One question they have for you

This increases the impact of your feedback.

2. Require Line-Numbered Revisions

Have students number the lines of their essay and then explain their revisions.

This makes improvements clearer for you and faster to assess.

3. Require a Conference First

Before revising, kids must…

Wait 24 hours
Complete a reflection form
Come prepared with questions for you

Make students do the thinking!

2. Require Highlighted Changes

Revisions should:

Be a new document
Include highlighted edits
Include explanations

Now there’s no time spent figuring out what changed.

Tech Tools That Help English Teachers Grade Faster

1. Use LMS Rubric Tools

Platforms like Canvas or Turnitin allow quick rubric scoring. Just click!

2. Build Comment Banks in Your LMS

Keep adding to them, and you’ll find you reuse them constantly.

3. Learn Keyboard Shortcuts

Less clicking = faster grading.

Final Thoughts: You Don’t Need to Grade Everything

You are not required to comment on everything, fix everything, or respond to everything.

Focus on what actually improves student writing and cut the rest.

That’s how you:

Save time
Stay effective
& Avoid burnout

🙂

Connect with Me!

What’s working in your classroom? How do you make grading faster and easier? How do you grade/assess/give feedback on essays?

Drop a comment below to help other teachers reading this blog!

Follow English with Mrs. Lamp:
📷 Pinterest | 🏫 TPT Store | 📧 Email Newsletter