The Fall of the House of Usher is one of Edgar Allan Poe’s most interesting and psychologically complex short stories. It’s a classic in high school English classrooms, but it’s also one of the toughest for students to read. I’ve taught this story for 13 years, and I’ve found that its dense language, Gothic imagery, and layered symbolism can intimidate even my stronger readers; however, with the right scaffolding, this story can become one of the most rewarding pieces you teach all year. It’s truly memorable for the students; in fact, you’ll find them referencing it months later!
Whether you’re building a Gothic literature unit or looking for a rigorous, engaging short story lesson for older high school (grades 11 & 12 or honors 10th grade), this guide will help you make The Fall of the House of Usher accessible, meaningful, and unforgettable for your students!
Note: I like to teach this during my month-long Gothic Lit unit (which works best in October)!
1. Start with Context to Build Student Confidence
Before diving into Poe’s 19th-century prose styling, we really do need to give students a foundation. I find that a short, modern-language introduction can make the difference between confusion and confidence.
👉 Tip: Provide a pre-reading text or background lesson/PowerPoint lecture that explains key Gothic elements (like crumbling houses, madness, and family curses) in accessible language. Use images/photos to bring it to life. Putting some time into giving a little background both builds anticipation and helps students enter Poe’s world ready to analyze the text, not just decode it.
💡 I include a 2-page intro reading in my full lesson to make Poe approachable from the start—especially for struggling readers.
2. Use “Stop and Ask” Questions to Guide Comprehension
Poe’s language is dense, and students often lose track of what’s happening or struggle to stick with the text at first. Embedding short comprehension and analysis questions during reading keeps them engaged and on track.
- Stop after each major paragraph or event.
- Ask targeted questions like:
- “How does the setting mirror the mood of the story?”
- “What does the narrator’s reaction to “X” reveal about his reliability?”
- Encourage written responses or quick pair-shares. Often, I guide students through taking notes or answering the during reading questions on a worksheet; this helps keep their attention and encourages them to listen and follow along with what we are doing.
This active reading strategy boosts comprehension and helps students tackle complex texts with confidence. They’ll be more likely to stick with you if they feel they CAN read and understand the text. They check out when they feel you’ve set them an impossible task.
3. Scaffold Literary Analysis with Clear Tools
Of course, we want students to grasp the plot, but we also want to guide them through deeper analysis. You can try one or more of these strategies:
- Graphic organizers where they’ll chart Gothic elements and symbols as they read
- Theme-based questions reading questions tied to the standards (RL.2, RL.3, RL.4, RL.5)
- Short written responses where they’ll write on narrator POV, symbolism, and/or psychological themes (Provide them with a prompt similar to an essay prompt, but let them respond in a small group with just 1-2 paragraphs.)
If you help them with a bit of scaffolding, students CAN be quite strong with their literary analysis; just make sure you’re intentionally guiding them with whatever activity you choose so that they can begin to see how Poe uses every detail (the house, the siblings, the storm) to build meaning! As you build your lesson, focus on trying to “wow” them with how author’s choices lead to themes or lessons & create a beautifully unified whole.
4. Make Assessment Meaningful
Instead of relying on a single test at the end, consider using a more flexible (and less time-consuming) quiz or a short analysis task to assess comprehension and critical thinking. You could include a mix of multiple choice, short answer, and passage-based close reading.
If you have a variety of ways to assess students, you can challenge your advanced kids and support your struggling learners at the same time; plus, you’ll have options each year that’ll help you be flexible if time constraints arise!
5. Bring It All Together with Engaging Discussion
Poe’s story is perfect for rich classroom conversations. We have fun in my class every year discussing the SPOOKY WEIRDNESS of this story! Ask students questions like:
- “Is the house a character in the story? Think about what that would mean…”
- “What is Poe saying about fear? How do you know?”
- “How reliable is the narrator? When can you tell he’s maybe not the most reliable narrator? Or what makes you think he IS reliable?”
I find that good class discussion helps EVERYBODY engage with our texts, and it makes the stories SO MUCH MORE MEMORABLE. Students will often remember a class discussion YEARS later, while they’ve forgotten stories that they read but did not discuss.
When students feel supported by the entire lesson (from the context building to the during-reading questions to the assessment types), even reluctant readers have strong opinions that’ll come out in class discussions, and I find that that’s often when the real learning happens.
Ready to Teach This Classic Poe Short Story with Confidence?
If you want a done-for-you lesson that includes teacher notes, a modern intro reading, embedded “stop & ask” questions, graphic organizers, and a flexible quiz, check out my Full Lesson Pack for The Fall of the House of Usher on TPT.
✅ 43 pages of ready-to-use resources
✅ Scaffolded support so you can reach ALL learners
✅ Common Core-aligned (RL.2, RL.3, RL.4, RL.5)
✅ Ideal for Grades 11, ,12, and high school Gothic literature units
With the right lesson plans and materials, Poe’s creepy classic can go from being one of those long slogs to being a powerful text that helps you build your students’ reading confidence AND analytical skills.
Leave a Reply