Analyzing theme in literary works is always a tough one for students. Whether it’s a short story, novel, play or poem, students often find themselves at a loss when it comes to moving beyond plot summarization to grasp the deeper meaning an author is trying to convey. Often, they simply try to Google it. We can do better than this!
It’s easy to see why inferring themes is hard for them. Heck, I remember going to the library when I was in high school so I could look up the themes of Huck Finn in a copy of Cliffs Notes. I felt like SUCH a cheater! But I just didn’t get it.
Inferring the unstated, universal truths within the pages of a great book requires sophisticated reasoning abilities that most young people haven’t had a lot of practice with. Many students lack the essential critical thinking strategies and habits of mind. In my case, I didn’t even know where to start, despite the fact that I KNOW my teacher had touched upon the themes of Huck Finn over the course of the lesson. I just couldn’t remember what a “theme” even was!
Teachers need to explicitly model HOW to figure out a theme. Otherwise, this vital skill is going to stay hard, scary, and mystifying for our students. We can’t assume students will figure it out independently or through osmosis. (My teachers did that a lot back in the day, unfortunately!) Just as we devote extensive time to strategies like finding the main idea or making inferences with informational texts, we must make our thought processes for determining theme much more clear and visible–even for high school students!!
An effective technique I have found includes using thought-provoking graphic organizers centered around character and/or plot. By breaking down the path experienced readers travel to arrive at a theme, we can transfer our mental approach onto paper: that’s where my SUPER SIMPLE graphic organizers come in! These make cognitive work students find opaque more concrete and followable.
The first organizer prompts focus on systematically examining aspects of plot development – conflicts, climaxes, character arcs, and resolutions. Take students through your own insight-building process by analyzing how each story progression is actually working to express a point of view, a truth, or a universal experience!
The second organizer focuses on character study, examining how protagonists’ traits, motivations, struggles, and changes can help us figure out the theme. Model inspecting characters’ moral dilemmas, flaws, blind spots, and growth to determine the work’s controlling idea!
Whether we choose to focus on plot or character (or maybe we do both organizers!), we MUST make our thought process for identifying theme SUPER transparent. Kids just don’t have the experience, otherwise, to figure it out on their own.
From there, it’s a matter of moving your kids from direct modeling to collaborative practice and then independent application. What started as an annoying mystery becomes an automatic habit of extended comprehension.
The ability to evaluate themes represents the deeper reading culture we hope to cultivate – equipping students as skilled analysts, thinkers, and citizens who can find truth in well-told stories. But it all starts with making the invisible process of interpretation visible through modeling and scaffolding. When we invest in these instructional supports, we’re not just teaching students how to tackle assigned texts. We’re teaching them how to appreciate the wisdom we find in great narratives–one of the big reasons we all love reading in the first place!
Leave a Reply